So I saw in the news today that a local woman has been arrested for murdering her mother. The 87 year old mother had severe dementia and was found in her home by a Hospice worker covered in feces and with multiple bedsores in various states of opening/healing. She was taken to a hospital and later died. She was in the care of her 65 year old daughter, who lived with her & is being charged with homicide. At her arrest the daughter stated, “I would have taken better care of [my mother] but I was just so tired.”
This whole story does not seem right. People don’t develop bedsores like the ones described overnight. And you can’t just spontaneously call Hospice and have them show up at your house whenever you want. Hospice isn’t 911. You have to be referred by your doctor to Hospice, and you don’t qualify until you are deathly ill and have no hope of recovery. Somebody had to have known what condition both of these women were in. And even supposing that there was an error in the reporting, are we really as a country just abandoning our senior citizens to the care of other senior citizens, with no help or assistance, just so we can then penalize whoever survives when it all goes to shit?
I am in no way trying to justify actual elder abuse or neglect, but if I were on this jury I would expect the prosecution to prove not only that the daughter (herself eligible for Social Security and Medicare) was capable of taking better care of her mother, had access to the means of better care, AND knew that the care she was providing was inadequate.
I’ve never heard of a murderer saying that they were just too tired. I have cared for seniors with dementia, and it is very exhausting on caregivers – professional caregivers, young and in good health themselves, who don’t have to care for a patient with only themselves for help 24 hours a day. I can’t imagine a 65 year old being the sole provider of this type of care. Either the daughter had help (in which case she is not solely responsible) or she did not have help (in which case the Texas health care system failed her and, again, she is not solely responsible). The fact that the victim was a Hospice patient means somebody should have been monitoring her condition. Probably multiple people. Doctors, nurses, aides, pharmaceutical staff. Or at least, during the time those bedsores were developing, somebody wrote down that they performed the required assessments. Don’t tell me that all of these people were charting care they supposedly gave (& definitely charged for) but nobody bothered to check how she was really doing. No, never mind, I believe it. I went to a local church a few times 10 years ago. They still beg me for money every month, send a pack of “donation” envelopes in the mail to my house. They have never once bothered to see how I’m doing, if I’m even still alive, but their money envelopes come like clockwork. That’s how things are done in “Christian” Texas. Why did Branch Davidians and FLDS pick Texas? Because in Texas, by the time the authorities bother to get off their asses it’s already too late.
To me, this case seems like another person died on Texas’ watch, and what with the Child Services & Foster Care fiasco currently going on, they decided it would be better for them to blame this one on the daughter than to admit that maybe our Mental Health & Adult Protective Services are just as deficient as our CPS. The daughter doesn’t exactly sound capable of providing much in the way of a defense. In fact her statement makes her seem mentally incompetent as well, so maybe the state of Texas was already monitoring her care. Maybe, instead of throwing her under the bus for her mother’s death, whoever was in charge of the daughter’s care should have realized she was in over her head, and done something before tragedy struck. But Texas doesn’t exactly have a good track record for preventing foreseeable tragedies. Ignore the problems; blame the victims. That’s Freedumb!
And supposing that the daughter is mentally fit, she is 65 years old. So when she needed help (as anybody would, let alone a senior citizen) in providing day to day care for her mother, just what do they think she should have done? Texas did not expand Medicaid. Nursing homes and hospitals all over the country have been struggling, but especially here in Texas. Even wealthy Parkland Hospital in Dallas laid off more than 500 people, and specifically sited the lack of Medicaid expansion as a reason. Many rural nursing homes and hospitals have closed, leaving not enough beds or care available. And many of the nursing homes left have cut their budgets so severely that the “care” they provide is barely legal, as they fail inspection after inspection. Homeless shelters are now dealing with an influx of senior citizens with problems they’re not equipped to handle: how to maintain a hip replacement when you’re sleeping rough, and the like. With the repeal of Obamacare looming over our heads, America is facing a very real Senior Homelessness Crisis, as more nursing homes shut down, and the elderly have no place to go. In a civilized society the 65 year old daughter should have been under care herself. In Capitalist America she’s being held liable for care she not only might not have been able to give, but might not have even had the ability to access for her mother either. This is insane. But in a country where corporations are never punished and poverty is a constant Catch-22, it is perfectly believable.
Now she could be a horrible person who just exploited her mother for her retirement money. But she wasn’t off taking a cruise or filling her house with luxury shopping items. She lived in the same deplorable conditions as her “victim.” And while she herself is a senior citizen, her “victim” was under the care of others: the Hospice people at the very least. It will be interesting to see how this case pans out, what details, if any, are eventually revealed.
A few months ago and woman was arrested for abuse of a disabled person, when the police found her naked adult daughter covered in her own filth in a dog cage. Her neighbors immediately jumped to the woman’s defense, saying that she was a “good mother.” Then not long after that police found a couple of toddlers in a backyard tied to a laundry line. They were naked and dirty and screaming and dehydrated. Their mother had no childcare and needed to work to support them. On the surface these all sound like horrible people. But dig a little deeper and they sound like desperate people with too few options in a society that is more ready to penalize than help. And if America wants to claim it’s a “Christian” nation, Hell if it wants to claim it’s a moral nation, then we are the keepers of our brothers sisters neighbors countrymen. We had better be willing to spend the tax dollars it takes to help people before things get this bad, instead of only being willing to fork over enough to punish them after we catch some desperate person choosing between options that are all bad. We could have offered each of these people a better choice. The choices they made suck, but can you really say with absolute certainty that they did these things out of hate? Maybe they were each exhausted and overwhelmed and desperate and just needed to do something so they could get to work on time. Maybe if each of these caregivers had had some help… Again, maybe they really are horrible people. But maybe they’re not. Maybe they had no help and really didn’t know what else to do. And in the cases of the disabled daughter and demented mother, both of them should have been in medical records somewhere. The medical personnel charging for their care and monitoring have some liability. They can’t just say after the fact “We didn’t know.” No, you didn’t bother to check. And you got paid for that. Probably with our tax dollars.